The S is exactly what it ought to be: the best-driving XE we’ve sampled to date. And that’s a heartening find, because bigger-engined petrol saloon cars don’t always hit that mark (unless they’re dedicated performance models built by specialist in-house tuners). Too often they fall victim, judged on added real-world performance and driver reward, to the law of diminishing marginal returns.
The 90deg V6 isn’t quite as characterful here as you’ll find it in the F-Type – but it’s close. You can hear just enough whine from the Roots-type supercharger to add a frisson of excitement and then a typically tuneful six-cylinder howl as the revs build.
There’s none of the snap, crackle and pop of unburnt fuel detonations that the F-Type layers on, but the XE S still has more compelling audible charm than most rival saloons would venture.
The car feels very swift on the road, but that engine is as impressive for its responsiveness and range as it is for its outright punch. Where a modern six-pot turbodiesel may offer almost as much speed as this but little of the sense of drama, the XE S combines pragmatism with panache to stirring effect.
Responding to lesser throttle openings, it chips in smartly with plenty of torque at low to medium revs, so the car feels muscular and easy to drive. Dig deeper with the accelerator and the gearbox is quick to change down but always judicious and decisive – provided you don’t change your mind about how hard you want the car to go.
Lock the car in gear using Dynamic mode and the gearshift paddles and you can wring out the engine beyond 6000rpm, ratio after smartly selected ratio. That gearbox gives you lots of cogs to choose from, and often the best one for a particular bend or overtake won't be the one you expect.
You’ll get used to it. The beauty is that, whether you want to use the last 1000rpm of the rev range in third gear or 300lb ft-plus of mid-range torque in sixth, the powertrain will obediently let you choose either – before richly and stoutly putting its shoulder to the wheel.
The XE S’s talents don’t stop there, either. We’ve now had experience of the standard passively damped XE, the sports-suspended car and this adaptively damped sports suspension, all on UK roads. So far, we haven’t found one combination of wheel, tyre, spring and damper we don’t like or that doesn’t work very well indeed. But the XE S’s particular tune is a work of rare brilliance, giving the car dynamic talents way above and beyond the ken of its competitors.
Join the debate
Add your comment
This car's biggest competition from BMWs Tuner Alpina
I'd honestly take one of
scrap wrote: I'd honestly
This is more a competitor for the 335i (now 340i) and, after test driving an XE and a 3, I can attest to how much better the Jaguar actually is. (I ended up going for a Mustang GT but hey-ho.)
The M3 competitor will be the XE-R. The V8 engine can fit inside the XE's bay, so that'll be something worth looking out for in the future.
@BigMitch
jer wrote: I've got and had
It was more the comment that "oh my, you don't have to spend 60K..to get a sports sedan".. Like no shit? It's like they literally live in testers paradise and have no real idea how people actually use and live with cars from day to day.
As for your other comment..well what's stopping you? Go by an Alfa sedan if you want "characterful petrol". Or do you need Autocar's say so for that too?