The 2024 Geneva motor show provided a classic case of being able to hold two conflicting opinions and believe both to be true.

You can call the show poor - although perhaps not the “pathetic” that one car maker did in private - yet still have enjoyed being there.

Geneva's problem was as much what it used to be rather than what it was. If a new show were set up in a different city and this were the result, we would probably be giving more credit for getting the manufacturers that did turn up there in the first place.

Still, the two halls were too stuffed with old cars and coffee shops; they would have been better just having the one open to create a bit more buzz and a busy feel. 

But let’s be honest: the Geneva decline started long before Covid, which was the catalyst for four subsequent cancellations of the show.

The 2019 show was down on exhibits and 2020 was looking light too, so follow that leakage of attendees and you might have ended up with the same size show as what occurred in 2024 anyway. 

Still, motor shows remain fine fare for us, simply because we get access to so many industry leaders in one place. I would call the below a fruitful day at work. Those talking up Geneva’s demise should be careful what they wish for.

Sunday evening

It was strange to arrive in Geneva and not have something like the Volkswagen Group night to attend, a usual prerequisite of a so-called big international motor show.

The biggest news on Sunday night actually came from Fiat, some guerilla marketing announcing its future product strategy and a preview of the new Panda in a video set in an Italian village called Ginevra. Yet it was late on a Sunday night, so it landed with a whimper, and what should have been a positive story just left people with more questions and nobody on hand at the show to answer them.

Why not just turn up at Geneva itself? By the time Monday morning came around, we had some cars we could look at and touch to write about and executives on hand to speak to them about. Fiat had been forgotten.

Car of the Year

Renault Scenic E-Tech with Car of the Year sticker

Car of the Year (COTY) is a big deal for car makers, and the announcement for the winner of the 2024 award had real tension as it turned into a two-horse race between the Renault Scenic E-Tech and the BMW 5 Series.