Refined motor is a pleasure to use, but the Passat lacks flair in a class that now offers practicality and character with no compromises

What is it?

This is the first time we've tested the familiar 120bhp 1.4 turbocharged petrol motor in the new Passat, and our first steer in the saloon variant in the UK, and it delivers exactly the sort of experience you would expect; that is a very accomplished and predictably dull one.

But we all know that the Passat is not about engaging its driver. It's about carrying people around comfortably and with the minimum fuss, and this model does it admirably – even in this base 'S' trim.

See pics of the Volkswagen Passat in action

What's it like?

Riding on the standard 16-inch alloys, the Passat can be slightly unsettled at lower speeds but it's not uncomfortable and generally it isolates occupants effectively, particularly at motorway speeds.

The cabin is underwhelming but feels solidly put together and entirely acceptable for this class, with enough space and usability to cater for the practicalities required of a family saloon. The base 'S' spec is equipped well, with air-con, leather multifunction wheel and USB input, which makes the Passat easy to live with even in entry-level guise.

The petrol motor also does the job required of it very well. It spins freely, is extremely quiet at idle, or with the standard stop-start on it restarts with noticeably less rattling and shuddering than a diesel motor will produce.

Whether it's around town or on the motorway the 1.4-litre engine continues to prove that (provided you don't push it into the upper rev ranges) it is more refined still than the already hushed diesel equivalent, and flexible enough that it doesn't feel strained as some might expect of a small petrol engine in a heavy car. In fact, mated to the standard six-speed gearbox it really is a very effective powertrain - usable, quiet and responsive.

And the economy? We returned an indicated 34mpg over varied motorway and urban usage, but high 30s should be achievable.

Should I buy one?

When you realise that the equivalent 1.6 TDI model is less than £800 more and is significantly cheaper to run (in terms of tax and fuel) it's obvious why some still struggle to see the point in small petrol engines in big models like the Passat.

These are cars that are more than likely to cover many miles and see hard use, so where are the benefits over the more frugal diesel? Well, in a word, refinement. If you like the Passat and running costs are top of your priority list then the diesel model is still the best option. But if your miles are lower then don't discount the petrol motor as in some ways it's more pleasant to use and it shouldn't be costly to run by general class standards.

Even with all these objective merits, the Passat is tricky to recommend given that there are rivals from Ford and Skoda that offer a more interesting experience and are equally competent at meeting the essential requirements of the class. The VW is a decent, worthy competitor but there are better cars in the class.

Volkswagen Passat 1.4 TSI

Factfile: Price: £18,875; Top speed: 127mph; 0-62mph: 10.3sec; Economy: 47.9mpg; Co2: 138g/km; Kerb weight; 1451kg; Engine type: 1390cc, 4cyl, turbocharged petrol; Power: 120bhp at 5000rpm; Torque: 148lb ft at 1500rpm; Gearbox: 6spd manual

Back to top

Join the debate

Add a comment…
Ritsaart 15 January 2011

Re: Volkswagen Passat 1.4 TSI

In European comparison tests the new Passat beats all its competitors. Only the Superb won once, the Mondeo came close and the others(Laguna, Insingnia, C5, Avensis, A4, C, S60 were beaten with a large margin. It may look a bit dull, but it is a car without flaws.

marj 12 January 2011

Re: Volkswagen Passat 1.4 TSI

sero wrote:
Renault Laguna is much better car !

True, and considering you can get a Laguna Dynamique TomTom dCi 150 FAP eco2 for £16,500 which is faster, better looking, more comfortable, better specced, more reliable and more economical, know where I'd spend my money.

marj 12 January 2011

Re: Volkswagen Passat 1.4 TSI

weenedonpetrol wrote:
But what it really like in a large car with four people and a boot load of luggage

Don't know about the Passat, but in the Golf with 4 people and a full boot on the Autobahn, it is p*ss poor. It somehow manages to be gruff and whiney with no power off boost, so you have to thrash it to get anywhere. So I can only assume this will be worse.

I also wonder how these tiny, highly tuned engines stand up to years of abuse compared to a conventional 1.8. i'm only saying as I;ve seen rather a lot of Golfs on teh back of recovery vehicles lately.

I'm personally not a fan of the Passat, I liked the hatch from the 80s and the 90s blob, but these latest ones just seem overpriced and poorly built with none of the Germanic trade-offs.